LBANY, March 28 — Nearly every
time a shovel breaks ground for downtown development here, it strikes something
from the deep past: In recent years, archaeologists hired to do pre-construction
surveys have found Dutch cemeteries, American Indian artifacts and, most
recently, an 18th-century rum distillery.
And just as often, the shovel keeps on going: All of those discoveries
have been unceremoniously reburied. Just last Friday, the city dumped backfill
over the distillery's vine-tied wooden fermentation vats to make way for
a six-story parking garage.
Today, however, Mayor Gerald D. Jennings, who has been pilloried in
the local press as lacking foresight and an appreciation of his city's
history, announced that he had hired a professor from the State University
at Albany to coordinate "our archaeological issues" and create a formal
plan for preserving future discoveries.
In addition, the president and chairman of First Albany Corporation,
Alan Goldberg and George McNamee, respectively, pledged $40,000 to extricate
and preserve some of the distillery — which now will have to be unearthed
again.
Mr. McNamee says he was inspired to make the donation after taking his
6-year-old son to see the distillery, which was discovered on Quackenbush
Square in December and has been drawing crowds for the last month.
The distillery, which operated from 1750 to 1810, includes 18 vats connected
with an intricate system of wooden pipes, a still, a fireplace, a privy
and the foundation of the manager's house.
"We're making personal gifts to underwrite the project because we'd
like to see as much attention given to preserving the city's antiquities
as possible," Mr. Goldberg said. "These are outstanding examples of life
300 years ago — apparently there was a lot of rum drunk here — and we're
hoping the city will find some additional money to preserve more of it."
Perhaps the 4,000 visitors who crammed the distillery site before last
week's burial, packing restaurants and clearing gift shop shelves at the
nearby Albany Visitors Center, convinced Mayor Jennings that it might be
worthwhile to make more of his city's 375-year history, especially in light
of his efforts to revitalize the downtown. But he said this had always
been his intention.
"It's not a change of heart on my part," he said. "We've undergone a
billion dollars' worth of growth and development in the last six years,
and for a city that was dormant for so long, we had to prioritize."
Assemblyman John J. McEneny, who represents the district where the distillery
stands and has written a book on Albany history, said the mayor — with
whom he often disagrees — should be commended for responding to a public
outcry.
"It's a step in the right direction," he said. "When you find the visible
remains of the 17th or 18th century, the first reaction should be `Wow!
This is tremendous.' But too often it's `Oh no, this is going to delay
everything.' I've had literally dozens of calls and e-mails asking to save
this site. And I believe there can be compromise."
To that end, Mr. McEneny has suggested enclosing the distillery in glass
and building the parking garage around it — in the same way, he said, that
a subway station in Mexico City displays Aztec ruins. That suggestion has
been scoffed at by the chairman of the Albany Parking Authority, who says
people will not visit a historic exhibit in a garage.
Preserving the vats in a museum would be the assemblyman's second choice.
But others want the distillery to remain where it is.
"To remove a vat and stick it on a museum shelf does not for me hold
as much resonance looking at it in its context," said Dennis Holzman, an
antiques dealer who brought his 12- year-old daughter, Martha, to see the
distillery on Saturday and left angry that all she could see were backhoes
and bulldozers.
There is no consensus yet on where the rescued vats — eight feet wide,
five feet high — will finally rest, and many may stay buried under the
garage.
But their unexpected debut in the 21st century has already made a lasting
impression.
A. Nancy Avakian, a retired university administrator who works at the
Visitors Center, was shocked to learn that Albany-made rum had been part
of the slave trade between Europe, Africa and the New World.
"They certainly didn't teach us anything about that in fourth grade,"
she said.
But Dr. Avakian takes the long view. "A hundred years from now somebody
will take down that parking garage and plow over it to build something
else," she said. "That's how things are. It's sad or it's progress, depending
on how you look at it."